It took me three viewings of Endgame to finally process how I actually feel about this gargantuan movie.
To put it simply, the sheer scope of Endgame makes it difficult to properly review. It not only possesses its own expansive story and intricate arcs for each character, but it also has the previous 22 movies riding on its shoulders to conclude in a satisfactory manner. A similar sentiment could be expressed during last year’s Infinity War, though last time Thanos was the primary character. These two films, especially Endgame, have the frustratingly impossible task of providing something both familiar and ambitious simultaneously. No other film franchise has come close to delivering as massive a cinematic universe like this, and it is impressive to see how far they’ve come. Whether you love it or hate it, the MCU is a trailblazing juggernaut of cinematic achievement. Endgame is no exception to this rule, and like its predecessor, effectively redefines the franchise once again.
The obvious question is, does it pay off? Ultimately, yes. Endgame is absolutely incredible and deserving of its success and high acclaim. That said, it isn’t a perfect conclusion to the Infinity Saga, nor can I say it is my favorite MCU film. My primary issues have more to do with certain plot points I’m not sure I’m sold on yet. Regardless, what Marvel and its cast and crew have achieved in this cinematic event is nothing short of astounding. Endgame does a fantastic job of balancing nostalgia and fan service while delivering its own messages that resonate deeply with its audiences. The original cast is really given their chance to shine for potentially the last time (depending on how the future plays out).
Concerning Thanos, I understand that this film is supposed to be focused on the Avengers, and understandably so. But we really hadn’t seen Thanos much until Infinity War, and he was one of the best things about it. It took the MCU a long time to make him into a compelling and threatening villain. His minor cameos in Guardians of the Galaxy, Age of Ultron and Avengers did very little to build any real excitement for the character for me. Those cameos often featured a more cartoony portrayal of the Mad Titan. The VFX work for Thanos in Infinity War and Endgame is so good, it’s disappointing we’ve only just now seen a proper depiction of the character.
Endgame also feels way more personal this time around. Each character tries to find their own way to deal with the aftermath of Thanos’ victory. Their emotions and interactions feel rawer and unhinged. We’ve rarely seen a more broken portrayal of our heroes before. This is tragically evident within the first moments. After Tony and Nebula are reunited with the remaining Avengers, it becomes abundantly clear how broken and defeated they are. Stark especially feels the weight of their failure, but also feels betrayed by Captain America and holds him responsible for breaking up the team. But Stark’s points are understandable. Their team’s fragmented state definitely contributed to their defeat and Steve’s actions directly led to their collapse, for better or worse. Regardless of what side you fall on in Civil War, both perspectives are understandable and ended in a tragic manner that made the Avengers vulnerable when their biggest threat finally showed himself. Stark and Rogers’ argument in this scene is simply heartbreaking.
The somber tone of the first act is established following one of the most shocking moments when Carol Danvers decides to go after Thanos, and what follows. The Avengers along with newly recruited Carol Danvers track down Thanos on his “Garden” planet, quickly subduing him and discovering that Thanos has destroyed the stones entirely. In a fit of rage, Thor decapitates the Mad Titan mid-sentence in a moment more tragic than victorious. Despite achieving his vengeance, Thor realizes Thanos still won, as they now have no way to reverse the snap. Of course, even sparing Thanos wouldn’t have changed anything. If the Decimation of seemingly countless beloved heroes wasn’t enough to bear, the lasting effects are even worse for everyone.
This kicks off a time jump of five years, where we find our heroes trying to move on from their failure to stop Thanos. It’s a dreary existence for everyone, apparently, and the first hour tragically depicts this. The crippled Avengers try and make the most of their new reality, albeit with resistance. And some do move on, like Tony Stark, who we discover has since married Pepper Potts and is now raising a young daughter. Stark clearly blames himself most of all for their failure, realizing that no amount of technological advances were enough to stop the Mad Titan in an all-out brawl. Hawkeye, having lost his entire family, chooses to throw himself into the world of vigilantism. Captain America is seen leading a support group, something akin to what his close friend, Sam Wilson used to do before his tragic death.
The criticism against Endgame is often levied against the first hour, and while I could understand how the slower pace can be a turn off for fans, it makes sense for this to occur from a narrative standpoint. Endgame simply doesn’t play out like its predecessor, nor any MCU film before it. Seeing the actual consequences of our heroes losing is something pretty jarring for us as an audience, and that slow burn of our characters’ failures is hard to swallow. It’s one of the reasons why it’s not as accessible of a film as some previous entries in the MCU. It feels dreary because it is – losing is not something we want to see our heroes typically do, and rarely does it happen with real consequences.
Narratively speaking, the methodical first hour is pure Marvel gold, but it’s a detraction from what we’re accustomed to. Infinity War rarely slowed down in comparison, while Endgame asks its audiences to be patient with its plot, focusing on its characters for the first hour instead of grand action pieces. Personally, I would have preferred more action in the first hour, but I think what the Russos and the writers chose to pursue instead is a more tasteful approach. For the finality of Endgame to work, audiences needed to be reminded of the greatness of these characters, and why they will stand the test of time in cinematic history. The callbacks and fan service are great, but these slower intimate moments are much deeper than most MCU films have offered until now. It’s also important to note that Infinity War ended on a cliffhanger, and we didn’t really get a chance to see the fallout of those events until Endgame, so a slow buildup makes sense in this regard.
As is the case with Infinity War, the VFX work here is top-notch. The motion-capture work done with Mark Ruffalo as Professor Hulk is stellar, and it’s a nice evolution for the character. I would have preferred them to give the Hulk more of a role other than just his scientific abilities, but it’s fine. It’s more substantive than the maddening plot depicted in Infinity War, which saw the Hulk essentially refuse to show up again after getting beaten badly in the opening scene. At least Banner has one of the coolest moments in Endgame, fulfilling the role as the one to reverse Thanos’ actions. Hulk’s snap leaves him crippled, though, like Thanos in the opening sequence.
The second and third act is where the VFX work really shines. I don’t know how they maintain quality in a film featuring this amount of CG shots, but it’s downright astounding. The final battle with Thanos and his army vs, well, everyone – is nothing short of incredible. There are some moments that are perhaps a bit heavy with the CG effects, but it is all done with great quality. The Russos have really grown as filmmakers, both from a visual standpoint and in their ability to blend actual drama with these fantastic set-pieces. The cinematography is likewise just as beautiful as any MCU film before, if not raising the bar significantly. There are some truly gorgeous shots in Endgame, and I have no doubt we’ll be talking about them for a long time.
Speaking of the final battle, it was surprising to see Thanos as powerful as he was without the Infinity Stones. There’s some debate about this, but it’s important to keep in mind the Thanos of Endgame in the final battle is one set on the complete destruction of the universe. Once he sees the future in his own timeline, his motivations change quickly. There is no holy mission of creating balance anymore – he is an all-out war with the Avengers to destroy them all. I would have liked to see Thanos play a larger role in Endgame, as he more than made a powerful impression as the ultimate baddie last time around, but at least when he is onscreen, he shines. It would be nice to see Brolin reprise the role in a flashback or prequel of some kind at least. Finding a suitable replacement villain for the next era of the MCU won’t be easy. Thanos is one of the best villains in cinematic history, and I’m not saying that lightly.
What makes Endgame so great is how it manages to provide a fantastic sense of fan service without being overdone, while at the same time giving the Avengers their best moments yet. I can’t say I loved every character’s arc, but overall, this is movie is essentially a love letter to the Avengers and their fans. And yet, it’s all done in a refreshing and ambitious manner, avoiding the common mistakes other franchises have done in this regard. The time heist, one of the centerpieces of the plot, is amazing. As each character explores the past, we’re treated to some hilarious and heartwarming moments. The Battle of New York was a fun callback, especially with moments like the Captain America vs. Captain America duel, Hulk taking the stairs and frustrated the whole time, Loki getting another chance to shine briefly in his classic mischevious manner. Even though it’s clearly stated in Endgame that time travel doesn’t work like it does in Back to the Future, I found myself just giddy with each scene as the Avengers revisit the past. It’s just fun, and even if it’s kind of confusing, I don’t really care. Anytime a movie or show introduces a time-travel element, it always produces some continuity issues or plot issues, so I don’t need Endgame to explain itself perfectly for it to work. It just needs to work without destroying the past.
Compared to many MCU films of the past, I think Endgame provides one of the most balanced approaches to humor and drama. One of the weaknesses of the MCU has been perhaps an overabundance of humor, even being inserted into moments that really don’t warrant it. I had this issue with Guardians of the Galaxy 2, Age of Ultron, and at times, Infinity War. Humor is certainly an appealing aspect of these films, but if there’s never a moment of real emotional weight, it can feel shallow. Endgame has some of the funniest moments in the MCU, while also depicting some of the most tragic. Few films have managed this balance, and I applaud Marvel for getting it right.
Now onto some of my more mixed feelings about Endgame.
I was curious to see how Captain Marvel was going to be handled, considering the controversy surrounding Brie Larson’s public comments during the marketing. I’ve been conflicted about Carol Danvers as a character. I enjoyed Captain Marvel as a film, but I found her portrayal to be problematic. She’s had her moments of greatness, but since her development was handled so poorly in Captain Marvel, I’m still waiting to really be sold on her character. I don’t understand why Brie Larson’s portrayal comes across as so wooden at times, as though they wrote her to be a character with little to no emotion. This makes no sense to me. I’m honestly beginning to think Brie Larson just wasn’t the right choice for the role. For a franchise that has given us some amazing female characters, Carol Danvers lacks the heart and charisma of her peers like Scarlett Johannson’s Natasha Romanoff/Black Widow, or Elizabeth Olsen’s Wanda/Scarlett Witch. Carol Danvers’ emotional range seems very limited for some reason in comparison. Her limited role in the film is probably for the best, as it allows the original team and the other more established characters to take center stage, some for the last time.
The responsibility of bringing so many films full circle while staging room for the future is an impossible task, and yet I believe the Russos have largely delivered exactly that. But with a film as ambitious as this, it makes sense that some things may not work for everyone. Thor’s arc is no exception. After he kills Thanos, the next time we see him he’s become a gross, overweight couch potato playing Fortnite and nursing a beer gut of shocking proportions. At first, I thought it was being played only for laughs. But the moment we see Thor’s reaction to hearing Thanos’ name, I realized this was not a laughing matter anymore. Thor has been drinking away his sorrows, and understandably so. He’s lost his entire family, many friends, and it was his inability to quell his need for vengeance that directly led to Thanos achieving his goal, which also gave the Mad Titan time to ensure they could not undo his actions. I can’t say I love a beer gut on Thor, but his arc is perhaps one of the most compelling in Endgame, especially when it comes full circle when he’s given the chance to have a truly heartwarming discussion with his mother in the past. This scene alone provides the brevity needed to prevent Thor’s arc from becoming simply a comedic side-plot. Thor’s arc in the MCU may just be one of the best. I know others may not feel that way, however. It is certainly a subject of much debate.
I can’t say I loved Steve Rogers becoming old and living out his days in the past with Peggy. Captain America has been my favorite MCU character for a long time now, but even I felt like it would be more fitting for him to die in battle than what Endgame portrays. I understand why Chris Evans wants to move on with the character, but for Rogers to choose to live out his days with Peggy didn’t sit well with me. Even early in the film, Steve tells his support group about Peggy and his life before he was frozen, but also how he understood the need to move on. It feels a bit contradictory. And seeing Evans portrayed as an old man is a bit jarring, as is the case anytime an actor is made to look significantly older. His choice to pass on the mantle of Captain America to Sam Wilson is also a bit problematic for me, as Wilson doesn’t possess any superhuman strength, for one thing. I had thought Bucky would be the obvious choice, but with Bucky’s dark past when he was under the control of Hydra, it’s also problematic for him to assume the role. As tragic as it would be for Rogers to never get the chance to live the life he wanted with Peggy, tragic death in battle against Thanos would have been more memorable to me and more emotionally impactful. If Rogers has to leave the MCU, he should have gone out with a bang, in my opinion.
I still cannot believe at times that Tony Stark is really gone. He’s definitely the focus of Endgame, and when we catch up with him five years after Thanos’ death, there is a sense of acceptance for his character. Stark believes he’s been given a second chance, and though he couldn’t stop Thanos, at least he gets to have the family he’s always wanted. It’s a beautiful arc for him, which makes his eventual decision to help the team and acquire the Infinity Stones all the more bittersweet. His breakthrough in achieving the means of time travel with laser precision is yet another example of how central his character has been to the MCU. Stark truly is the heart of the MCU, and it’s fitting for his leadership to be a large part in helping the team achieve their goal. I loved the scene when Tony drives up and has a nice moment of reconciliation with Steve, a scene we’ve been waiting for now since Civil War. Tony’s finest hour is definitely Endgame, and in the climactic moment where he finally defeats Thanos is just pure cinematic gold.
There’s a lot more to be said about Endgame, certainly. It’s a massive film, and the production values are incredible, including the particularly riveting score by Alan Silvestri. The Russo brothers have delivered on their promises and their ambition since The Winter Soldier has clearly kept the MCU from becoming stale. Endgame will no doubt go down in history has one of the best conclusions to any franchise. And with its finality, I feel a sense of closure for my own investment as a fan. Regardless of where Marvel takes things next, I doubt they will ever top what’s been achieved here. The loss of Captain America and Tony Stark, two of my favorite characters, is also too big a pill to swallow for me to simply move on to the next phase. And while Endgame isn’t a perfect film, it is nearly everything it promised to be and more. Huge props to Marvel and the whole cast and crew for pulling off this incredible cinematic event. No other film franchise has managed to weave together so many different films of different tones, themes, plot, and characters with such quality.
Final Score: 9.3/10